The Tin Box is another great place to visit. We love going for Happy Hour and getting oysters. Super fresh and very affordable. The Mac & Cheese is to die for as well. Plus the jungle views are pretty cool and they have a lot of great drinks made with fresh squeezed juice and herbs from their garden.
If you want something a little fancier for dinner I would recommend El Quenepo. It's in Esperanza and right on the water with an upscale atmopsher and great menu. There are several other great places on the Island these are just a few of our top picks that are on repeat whenever we visit.